50% success rate. The search continues...

What I loved about the twenty-five or so other ones I’ve tried (that went away for whatever reason), is that I could just click the menu bar item and get a list of what I want to paste… well, Paste will have none of that. You have to proactively open it and get squares across the bottom of the screen, double-click your choice, and then paste all over again. That’s lame, but the real deal-breaker here is the fact that it just plain doesn’t work half the time. I copy, I paste, but it pastes something old. The thing I just copied…? Didn’t copy. Why? Don’t know. I’ve actually started hitting Command-C about four or five times just to be sure… and that’s no way to live. So, no, Paste is not the app you’re looking for. Move along. Sigh.

thestuntman about Paste - Endless Clipboard